These scary would you rather questions bring the shivers without the nightmares. They are spooky in a fun way: haunted houses, creaky stairs, glowing eyes in the dark, friendly ghosts and mysterious sounds. There is no gore, no violence and nothing gross, so they work for kids, classrooms, sleepovers and family nights around a flashlight.
To play, turn the lights down, hold a flashlight under your chin and read one question in your spookiest voice. Everyone picks a side, then tells what they would do next. For younger kids, skip the darkest picks and stay with the silly scares section.
On this page:
- Scary would you rather questions about haunted places
- Scary would you rather questions about creepy critters
- Spooky would you rather questions about mysteries
- Silly scary would you rather questions
- Scary would you rather questions about spooky powers
Scary would you rather questions about haunted places
Would you rather spend a night in a haunted castle or spend a night in a haunted lighthouse?
Castle or lighthouse.
Vote and see results →Would you rather explore a creaky attic or explore a dark basement?
Up or down.
Vote and see results →Would you rather walk through a foggy graveyard at dusk or walk through a dark forest at night?
Fog or trees.
Vote and see results →Would you rather hear footsteps upstairs when no one is home or hear a music box playing by itself?
Steps or song.
Vote and see results →Would you rather stay in a hotel room where the lights flicker or stay in a hotel room where the doors creak?
Flicker or creak.
Vote and see results →Would you rather find a secret door behind a bookcase or find a hidden staircase under the floor?
Door or stairs.
Vote and see results →Would you rather visit an abandoned amusement park or visit an empty old school at night?
Rides or halls.
Vote and see results →Would you rather sleep in a room with a painting whose eyes follow you or sleep in a room with a mirror that whispers?
Eyes or whispers.
Vote and see results →Would you rather get lost in a corn maze after dark or get stuck in a haunted elevator?
Maze or lift.
Vote and see results →Would you rather live next to a spooky old mansion or live next to a misty swamp?
Mansion or swamp.
Vote and see results →Would you rather ride a ghost train or ride a haunted carousel?
Train or carousel.
Vote and see results →Would you rather open a door that has been locked for 100 years or open a chest that has been buried for 100 years?
Door or chest.
Vote and see results →Would you rather explore a cave with glowing walls or explore a tunnel with echoing voices?
Glow or echo.
Vote and see results →Would you rather spend Halloween in a spooky museum or spend Halloween in a spooky library?
Museum or library.
Vote and see results →Would you rather see a candle light up by itself or see a rocking chair rock by itself?
Candle or chair.
Vote and see results →Would you rather find a map to a haunted island or find a key to a haunted tower?
Island or tower.
Vote and see results →Would you rather hear thunder in a big empty house or hear howling in a tiny cabin?
Thunder or howl.
Vote and see results →Would you rather walk across a wobbly rope bridge at night or walk down a long hallway with no lights?
Bridge or hall.
Vote and see results →Would you rather stay in a tree house during a storm or stay in a tent during a storm?
Tree or tent.
Vote and see results →Would you rather visit a town where everyone wears masks or visit a town where no one ever talks?
Masks or silence.
Vote and see results →Scary would you rather questions about creepy critters
Would you rather hold a big hairy spider or hold a long slithery snake?
Spider or snake.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a bat fly around your room or have an owl stare at you all night?
Bat or owl.
Vote and see results →Would you rather find a frog in your shoe or find a beetle in your hat?
Shoe or hat.
Vote and see results →Would you rather meet a black cat on a dark road or meet a crow that can talk?
Cat or crow.
Vote and see results →Would you rather walk through a room full of cobwebs or walk through a room full of moths?
Webs or moths.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have glowing eyes watch you from the bushes or hear a howl from the hills?
Eyes or howl.
Vote and see results →Would you rather let a moth land on your nose or let a ladybug crawl up your arm?
Moth or ladybug.
Vote and see results →Would you rather find a nest of crickets under your bed or find a family of mice in your closet?
Chirp or squeak.
Vote and see results →Would you rather see a giant squid from a boat or see a giant moth on your window?
Squid or moth.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be followed by a curious raccoon at night or be followed by a curious goose at night?
Raccoon or goose.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a raven as a sidekick or have a black cat as a sidekick?
Raven or cat.
Vote and see results →Would you rather hear rustling in the leaves or hear scratching on the window?
Leaves or window.
Vote and see results →Would you rather swim in a lake with a legendary monster or hike in woods with a legendary beast?
Lake or woods.
Vote and see results →Would you rather find a glowing worm or find a glowing mushroom?
Worm or mushroom.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be friends with a vampire bat or be friends with a werewolf puppy?
Bat or pup.
Vote and see results →Would you rather hear a wolf howl at the full moon or hear an owl hoot at midnight?
Howl or hoot.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have spiders spell your name in a web or have fireflies spell your name in the sky?
Web or sky.
Vote and see results →Would you rather see a shadow of a giant cat or see a shadow of a giant bird?
Cat or bird.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a lizard nap on your pillow or have a toad nap in your slipper?
Pillow or slipper.
Vote and see results →Spooky would you rather questions about mysteries
Would you rather follow a ghost who gives directions or follow a lantern that floats by itself?
Ghost or lantern.
Vote and see results →Would you rather find out your house is haunted by a nice ghost or find out your toy comes alive at night?
Ghost or toy.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a mirror that shows the future or have a mirror that shows the past?
Future or past.
Vote and see results →Would you rather solve the mystery of a vanishing house or solve the mystery of a town that disappears in fog?
House or town.
Vote and see results →Would you rather get a letter from your future self or get a letter from a stranger 100 years ago?
Future or past.
Vote and see results →Would you rather wake up and everyone else is asleep or wake up and everyone else is a shadow?
Asleep or shadows.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a doll that winks at you or have a clock that runs backward?
Wink or tick.
Vote and see results →Would you rather hear your name whispered in an empty room or see your name written in the fog on a window?
Hear or see.
Vote and see results →Would you rather find a door to a different world in your closet or find a portal at the bottom of a pool?
Closet or pool.
Vote and see results →Would you rather live in a town where it is always night or live in a town where it is always foggy?
Night or fog.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be able to talk to ghosts or be able to see invisible creatures?
Talk or see.
Vote and see results →Would you rather find an old diary that writes back or find an old phone that rings with no one there?
Diary or phone.
Vote and see results →Would you rather meet your double in the street or see your reflection move on its own?
Double or mirror.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a dream that comes true every night or have someone else's dream every night?
Yours or theirs.
Vote and see results →Would you rather discover a secret tunnel under your school or discover a secret room in your house?
School or home.
Vote and see results →Would you rather hear a radio play messages from the past or see a TV show your family from the future?
Radio or TV.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a mysterious package arrive every Friday or have a mysterious note in your bag every Monday?
Package or note.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be the only one who can see the ghost or be the only one the ghost cannot see?
See or hidden.
Vote and see results →Would you rather live in a painting for a day or live inside a storybook for a day?
Painting or book.
Vote and see results →Would you rather find footprints that lead nowhere or find a trail of glowing pebbles?
Prints or pebbles.
Vote and see results →Silly scary would you rather questions
Would you rather have a ghost that tells bad jokes or have a ghost that sings off-key?
Jokes or songs.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be chased by a slow zombie snail or be chased by a tiny angry pumpkin?
Snail or pumpkin.
Vote and see results →Would you rather meet a vampire who is afraid of the dark or meet a monster who is afraid of mice?
Dark or mice.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a skeleton that dances at night or have a mummy that tickles your feet?
Dance or tickle.
Vote and see results →Would you rather hide from a monster under the bed or invite the monster to a sleepover?
Hide or invite.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a witch's broom that sneezes or have a witch's cat that hiccups?
Sneeze or hiccup.
Vote and see results →Would you rather scare a ghost by accident or be scared by your own shadow?
Ghost or shadow.
Vote and see results →Would you rather wear a costume you can never take off or change costumes every hour?
Stuck or swap.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a jack-o'-lantern that talks or have a scarecrow that waves?
Talk or wave.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be a werewolf who loves knitting or be a vampire who loves gardening?
Knit or garden.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a haunted house that is very polite or have a haunted house that is very messy?
Polite or messy.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a ghost do your homework or have a ghost clean your room?
Homework or room.
Vote and see results →Would you rather find a spider wearing tiny shoes or find a bat wearing tiny glasses?
Shoes or glasses.
Vote and see results →Would you rather trick-or-treat at a castle or trick-or-treat on a pirate ship?
Castle or ship.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a zombie as your gym teacher or have a mummy as your librarian?
Gym or library.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have your teeth glow in the dark or have your hair glow in the dark?
Teeth or hair.
Vote and see results →Would you rather go to a monster dance party or go to a ghost movie night?
Dance or movie.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be friends with a shy monster or be friends with a loud ghost?
Shy or loud.
Vote and see results →Scary would you rather questions about spooky powers
Would you rather walk through walls like a ghost or turn into a bat and fly?
Walls or wings.
Vote and see results →Would you rather see in total darkness or hear sounds from a mile away?
See or hear.
Vote and see results →Would you rather make things float like magic or make things invisible like magic?
Float or vanish.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a cape that makes you vanish or have boots that let you walk on ceilings?
Cape or boots.
Vote and see results →Would you rather cast spells with a wand or brew potions in a cauldron?
Wand or potion.
Vote and see results →Would you rather command an army of friendly bats or command an army of friendly spiders?
Bats or spiders.
Vote and see results →Would you rather glow in the dark or make others glow in the dark?
You or them.
Vote and see results →Would you rather hear what ghosts are thinking or see where ghosts are hiding?
Hear or see.
Vote and see results →Would you rather ride a skeleton horse or ride a giant black cat?
Horse or cat.
Vote and see results →Would you rather make any room feel cold or make any light flicker?
Cold or flicker.
Vote and see results →Would you rather shrink down to hide in a keyhole or stretch tall to peek over walls?
Shrink or stretch.
Vote and see results →Would you rather know when someone is scared or never feel scared yourself?
Sense or brave.
Vote and see results →Would you rather turn pumpkins into carriages or turn leaves into butterflies?
Pumpkins or leaves.
Vote and see results →Would you rather teleport through mirrors or teleport through puddles?
Mirrors or puddles.
Vote and see results →Would you rather make friends with any monster or make any monster disappear?
Friend or vanish.
Vote and see results →Frequently asked questions
Are these scary questions OK for kids?
Yes. They are spooky, not frightening: no blood, injuries, weapons or real-world dangers. Ghosts are friendly, monsters are silly, and every scene is the kind you would find in a kids Halloween book.
When should I use scary would you rather questions?
They are great for sleepovers, campfires, Halloween parties and October classrooms, but they work any time a group wants a little thrill. Read them in a whisper with the lights low for the best effect.
How do I make it spookier without being too scary?
Add sound effects, a flashlight and a slow voice, and let each player add a creepy detail to their answer. Keep the content light and stop if anyone feels uneasy; the fun is in the build-up.