Halloween Would You Rather questions about costumes, candy, pumpkins and friendly monsters. Spooky but never scary or gory, so they are great for kids, classrooms, trick-or-treat walks and costume parties.
How to play
Turn the lights down, use a flashlight and read the questions in your spookiest voice. Players who answer get a piece of candy. Want to play online instead? Press the Play button above to vote on each question and see what percentage of players agreed with you.
50 Halloween Would You Rather Questions
1. Would you rather go trick-or-treating or go to a Halloween party?
Door to door or dance floor.
Vote and see results →2. Would you rather dress up as a superhero or dress up as a monster?
Save the day or spook the night.
Vote and see results →3. Would you rather get only chocolate or get only sour candy?
Sweet treats or puckery treats.
Vote and see results →4. Would you rather visit a haunted house or go on a hayride through a corn maze?
Spooky rooms or spooky fields.
Vote and see results →5. Would you rather carve a pumpkin or paint a pumpkin?
Knife art or brush art.
Vote and see results →6. Would you rather be a friendly ghost or be a friendly vampire?
Float or fang.
Vote and see results →7. Would you rather have a costume that glows in the dark or have a costume that makes sounds?
Light show or sound show.
Vote and see results →8. Would you rather get a full-size candy bar from every house or get a handful of mixed candy from every house?
Quality or variety.
Vote and see results →9. Would you rather live in a haunted castle or live in a witch's cottage?
Big and spooky or small and magical.
Vote and see results →10. Would you rather have a pet black cat or have a pet bat?
Classic or flappy.
Vote and see results →11. Would you rather wear a costume to school for a week or wear a costume to school once but win the contest?
Long fun or one big win.
Vote and see results →12. Would you rather bob for apples or eat a caramel apple?
Wet face or sticky fingers.
Vote and see results →13. Would you rather watch a not-so-scary Halloween movie or tell spooky stories with a flashlight?
Screen or campfire.
Vote and see results →14. Would you rather be a witch who can fly or be a wizard who can cast spells?
Broomstick or wand.
Vote and see results →15. Would you rather have a pumpkin as big as a car or have a pumpkin patch in your backyard?
One giant or many small.
Vote and see results →16. Would you rather trade all your candy for one huge chocolate bar or keep all your candy?
Big win or big pile.
Vote and see results →17. Would you rather have candy corn or have candy apples?
The love-it-or-hate-it candy versus the classic.
Vote and see results →18. Would you rather have a costume made by your family or have a store-bought costume?
Handmade or fancy.
Vote and see results →19. Would you rather go trick-or-treating with friends or go trick-or-treating with family?
Squad or crew.
Vote and see results →20. Would you rather meet a friendly zombie who loves dancing or meet a friendly werewolf who loves cookies?
Monsters with hobbies.
Vote and see results →21. Would you rather have Halloween twice a year or have your birthday on Halloween?
Double spooky or birthday spooky.
Vote and see results →22. Would you rather decorate your house with spider webs or decorate it with glowing pumpkins?
Creepy or cozy.
Vote and see results →24. Would you rather fly on a broomstick or ride on a magic pumpkin?
Witchy or fairy-tale.
Vote and see results →25. Would you rather make your own candy or make your own costume?
Kitchen creator or costume creator.
Vote and see results →26. Would you rather have a Halloween party at a pumpkin farm or have a Halloween party in a castle?
Farm fun or castle fun.
Vote and see results →27. Would you rather be a scarecrow for a night or be a jack-o'-lantern for a night?
Stuffed or glowing.
Vote and see results →28. Would you rather get scared by a jump scare or get scared by creepy music?
Sudden or slow.
Vote and see results →29. Would you rather have a candy bucket that never gets full or have a candy bucket that sorts your candy?
Bigger haul or organized haul.
Vote and see results →30. Would you rather watch fireworks on Halloween or have a costume parade on Halloween?
Sky show or street show.
Vote and see results →31. Would you rather hand out candy at home or go out trick-or-treating?
Doorbell duty or street adventure.
Vote and see results →32. Would you rather have a ghost that does your homework or have a ghost that tells you jokes?
Helpful or funny spirit.
Vote and see results →33. Would you rather live next door to a friendly witch or live next door to a friendly vampire?
Potions or late-night visits.
Vote and see results →34. Would you rather have a costume that changes every hour or have the best costume of the night?
Variety or victory.
Vote and see results →37. Would you rather have a spooky treehouse or have a spooky basement?
Up high or down low.
Vote and see results →38. Would you rather win a pumpkin carving contest or win a costume contest?
Carving trophy or costume trophy.
Vote and see results →39. Would you rather have candy that makes you float or have candy that makes you invisible?
Floating fun or sneaky fun.
Vote and see results →41. Would you rather find a secret room in a haunted house or find a treasure map in a pumpkin?
Spooky secret or treasure hunt.
Vote and see results →42. Would you rather make a monster cake or make spider cookies?
Spooky baking either way.
Vote and see results →43. Would you rather be a ghost who can only say "boo" or be a witch who can only cackle?
Very limited conversations.
Vote and see results →44. Would you rather have a costume party at school or have a costume party at home?
Classmates or close friends.
Vote and see results →45. Would you rather have glowing eyes on Halloween night or have glowing hair on Halloween night?
Spooky glow.
Vote and see results →46. Would you rather collect 100 pieces of candy or collect 10 full-size bars?
Quantity or quality.
Vote and see results →47. Would you rather go to a pumpkin patch or go to an apple orchard?
Fall field trip choices.
Vote and see results →48. Would you rather have a Halloween movie night or have a Halloween game night?
Watch or play.
Vote and see results →49. Would you rather be a superhero on Halloween or be a villain on Halloween?
Good guy or bad guy, just for one night.
Vote and see results →50. Would you rather turn your house into a haunted maze or turn your yard into a pumpkin garden?
Maze maker or garden maker.
Vote and see results →Frequently asked questions
How do you play halloween Would You Rather?
Read a question out loud, everyone picks one of the two options, and each person explains why. No answering "both" or "neither". You can also tap a question here to vote online and see how other players chose.
Are these halloween questions family friendly?
Yes. Every question on WouldYouRather.info is clean and safe for kids, classrooms, families and work events.
How many halloween questions are there?
This page has 50 halloween Would You Rather questions, and we add new ones regularly.