These would you rather questions for middle school are written for 11 to 14 year olds and the adults who teach and raise them. Every question is clean and classroom-safe, covering lockers, group projects, friends, phones, sports, clubs and big future dreams. Teachers can use them for morning meetings, advisory periods and quick brain breaks, while parents can bring them out at dinner or on long car rides.
To play, read both options aloud and have everyone pick a side, then ask each person to give one reason. In class, students can move to opposite sides of the room or vote with a show of hands. For a writing task, turn any question into a persuasive writing prompt: pick a side, give three reasons and answer one counterargument.
On this page:
- Would you rather questions about middle school life
- Would you rather questions for middle schoolers about the future
- Would you rather questions about friends and fun
- Would you rather questions about games, tech and screens
- Would you rather questions about sports, clubs and hobbies
Would you rather questions about middle school life
Would you rather have a locker right next to every class or have a locker that never jams?
Speed or reliability.
Vote and see results →Would you rather switch classes every 30 minutes or stay in one classroom all day?
Hallway time matters.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a group project every week or have a pop quiz every week?
Teamwork or solo test.
Vote and see results →Would you rather get the top bunk on the class field trip or pick the seat on the bus home?
Trip perks.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have no homework but longer school days or have shorter days but double homework?
Time at school or home.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be the student council president or be the yearbook editor?
Leader or storyteller.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a teacher who tells great stories or have a teacher who gives easy tests?
Fun or easy grades.
Vote and see results →Would you rather present a science fair project on stage or write a ten-page report alone?
Spotlight or paperwork.
Vote and see results →Would you rather learn every lesson outside in the courtyard or learn every lesson in a cozy library?
Fresh air or quiet.
Vote and see results →Would you rather bring recess back for middle schoolers or get a lunch period twice as long?
Play or eat.
Vote and see results →Would you rather always remember your locker combination or never forget your gym clothes?
Two classic struggles.
Vote and see results →Would you rather read the morning announcements every day or run the school store at lunch?
Microphone or cash box.
Vote and see results →Would you rather take a class on building robots or take a class on making movies?
Tech or film.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a four-day school week with longer days or have five short school days?
Long weekend or short days.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be the first to finish every test or be the one who checks every answer twice?
Fast or careful.
Vote and see results →Would you rather get to choose your seat in every class or get to choose your lunch period?
Seat or schedule.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a class pet in homeroom or have a snack bar in homeroom?
Fluffy or tasty.
Vote and see results →Would you rather go on a field trip to a science museum or go on a field trip to a theme park?
Learning or thrills.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have every class taught by a different guest expert or keep the same teachers all year?
New faces or familiar.
Vote and see results →Would you rather win the school spelling bee or win the school talent show?
Brains or showtime.
Vote and see results →Would you rather questions for middle schoolers about the future
Would you rather invent something everyone uses every day or discover a new species in the rainforest?
Inventor or explorer.
Vote and see results →Would you rather become a famous chef with your own restaurant or become a famous game designer?
Kitchen or keyboard.
Vote and see results →Would you rather know exactly what job you will have or be surprised by where life takes you?
Plan or adventure.
Vote and see results →Would you rather live in a big city when you grow up or live in a quiet small town when you grow up?
Busy or peaceful.
Vote and see results →Would you rather travel to every country before age 30 or own your dream house before age 30?
Passport or keys.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be an astronaut on a mission to Mars or be an ocean scientist exploring the deep sea?
Up or down.
Vote and see results →Would you rather go to college in another country or go to college close to home?
Far or familiar.
Vote and see results →Would you rather write a bestselling book series or direct a blockbuster movie?
Pages or screens.
Vote and see results →Would you rather start your own business at 18 or work for a big company you admire?
Boss or team member.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be a doctor who helps people every day or be a teacher who inspires students every day?
Two ways to help.
Vote and see results →Would you rather learn to speak five languages fluently or learn to play five instruments well?
Words or music.
Vote and see results →Would you rather get your driver's license the day you turn 16 or get a bike that never gets a flat?
Freedom on wheels.
Vote and see results →Would you rather design buildings as an architect or design video games as a programmer?
Blueprints or code.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a summer job at an animal shelter or have a summer job at an amusement park?
Puppies or rides.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be remembered for being kind or be remembered for being brilliant?
Heart or mind.
Vote and see results →Would you rather peek at a letter from your future self or send one piece of advice to your past self?
Look ahead or look back.
Vote and see results →Would you rather make a big scientific discovery or win an Olympic gold medal?
Lab or podium.
Vote and see results →Would you rather live on a space station for a year or live on a research ship for a year?
Orbit or ocean.
Vote and see results →Would you rather stay in touch with your middle school friends forever or meet your closest friends later in life?
Old or new.
Vote and see results →Would you rather graduate high school a year early or take a gap year to travel after high school?
Fast track or explore.
Vote and see results →Would you rather questions about friends and fun
Would you rather have a sleepover every weekend or have one epic party at the end of the year?
Often or once and big.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a friend who always makes you laugh or have a friend who always gives good advice?
Funny or wise.
Vote and see results →Would you rather explore a corn maze with your crew or go mini golfing with your crew?
Maze or putt.
Vote and see results →Would you rather invent a nickname for your whole friend group or design matching T-shirts for your friend group?
Name or look.
Vote and see results →Would you rather plan the perfect birthday party for a friend or have a friend plan a surprise party for you?
Planner or guest.
Vote and see results →Would you rather build a giant pillow fort with friends or have a backyard campout with friends?
Indoors or outdoors.
Vote and see results →Would you rather sit with your best friend in every class or sit with your best friend at every lunch?
Class or cafeteria.
Vote and see results →Would you rather film a cooking show with your buddies or record a radio mystery with your buddies?
Kitchen or microphone.
Vote and see results →Would you rather text your best friend a riddle every morning or trade doodles with your best friend in study hall?
Riddles or doodles.
Vote and see results →Would you rather spend a snow day sledding with friends or spend a snow day baking cookies with friends?
Hills or ovens.
Vote and see results →Would you rather go to a water park with your class or go to an escape room with your class?
Splash or solve.
Vote and see results →Would you rather make a new friend every week or keep the same three friends forever?
New or loyal.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be the friend who always has snacks or be the friend who always has a plan?
Snacks or schedule.
Vote and see results →Would you rather write a comic book with your best friend or invent a board game with your best friend?
Story or rules.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a pen pal in another country or have a neighbor who is the same age as you?
Far away or next door.
Vote and see results →Would you rather spend the day at a carnival with friends or spend the day at the beach with friends?
Rides or waves.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be in the funniest friend group at school or be in the most creative friend group at school?
Laughs or ideas.
Vote and see results →Would you rather go on a road trip with your friend's family or have your friend join your family vacation?
Guest or host.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a friend who is amazing at art or have a friend who is amazing at fixing things?
Creative or handy.
Vote and see results →Would you rather throw a themed costume party or throw a karaoke party?
Dress up or sing out.
Vote and see results →Would you rather questions about games, tech and screens
Would you rather have a phone with unlimited battery or have a phone that never cracks?
Power or protection.
Vote and see results →Would you rather only play video games on weekends or play one hour every school day?
Binge or daily.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be able to build any app you imagine or be able to design any video game you imagine?
App or game.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have the fastest internet in the world or have the biggest screen in the world?
Speed or size.
Vote and see results →Would you rather live inside your favorite video game for a day or have one video game character visit you for a day?
Go in or bring out.
Vote and see results →Would you rather swap your phone for a flip phone for a month or use only the library computer for a month?
Old tech challenge.
Vote and see results →Would you rather win a gaming tournament online or win a robotics competition in person?
Controller or code.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a robot that does your chores or have a robot that helps with homework?
Chores or studying.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be a famous streamer or be a famous video editor?
On camera or behind it.
Vote and see results →Would you rather only use apps with no ads or only use apps with no loading screens?
Ads or waiting.
Vote and see results →Would you rather only play games that are in black and white or only play games with the sound off?
No color or no sound.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have VR goggles that take you anywhere or have headphones that translate any language?
See or hear.
Vote and see results →Would you rather learn to code your own website or learn to animate your own cartoon?
Code or draw.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a smartwatch that can read your mind or have glasses that show answers on tests?
Thoughts or answers.
Vote and see results →Would you rather only text in emojis for a week or only send voice messages for a week?
Pictures or voices.
Vote and see results →Would you rather play an old classic game console or play a brand-new console with one game?
Retro or new.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have a drone that films everything you do or have a 3D printer that makes anything small?
Film or build.
Vote and see results →Would you rather lose all your saved game progress or lose all the photos on your phone?
Painful either way.
Vote and see results →Would you rather design your own video game character or design your own video game level?
Hero or world.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have screen time limits set by you or have no screens but endless outdoor adventures?
Choice or freedom.
Vote and see results →Would you rather questions about sports, clubs and hobbies
Would you rather join the school soccer team or join the school basketball team?
Field or court.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be the fastest runner in your grade or be the best swimmer in your grade?
Track or pool.
Vote and see results →Would you rather join a chess club or join a skateboarding club?
Strategy or tricks.
Vote and see results →Would you rather score the winning goal in a big game or make the game-saving catch?
Offense or defense.
Vote and see results →Would you rather play in the school band or sing in the school choir?
Instrument or voice.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be captain of a losing team or be a bench player on a winning team?
Lead or win.
Vote and see results →Would you rather run a mile every morning or do 50 jumping jacks every hour?
All at once or spread out.
Vote and see results →Would you rather join the photography club or join the drama club?
Lens or stage.
Vote and see results →Would you rather compete in a math competition or compete in a cross-country race?
Brain or legs.
Vote and see results →Would you rather earn a black belt in taekwondo or land a back handspring on your first try?
Kicks or flips.
Vote and see results →Would you rather start a school newspaper or start a school podcast?
Print or audio.
Vote and see results →Would you rather play a sport in the snow or play a sport on the sand?
Cold or sandy.
Vote and see results →Would you rather be great at every sport but love none or love one sport but be average at it?
Talent or passion.
Vote and see results →Would you rather join the model rocket club or join the knitting club?
Launch or loop.
Vote and see results →Would you rather practice your hobby alone every day or practice your hobby with a team twice a week?
Solo or squad.
Vote and see results →Would you rather win a ribbon at the science fair or win a trophy at the sports banquet?
Ribbon or trophy.
Vote and see results →Would you rather learn to juggle five balls or learn to solve a puzzle cube in a minute?
Hands or brain.
Vote and see results →Would you rather have your own ping pong table or have your own basketball hoop?
Paddles or hoops.
Vote and see results →Would You Rather Activities for Middle School Classes
Middle schoolers like to share opinions and hear what classmates think. Would you rather questions give them a safe way to do both. These routines fit homeroom, advisory, and core classes.
- Bell Ringer Prompt. Post a question on the board as students walk in. They write their answer and one reason in their notebook before class starts.
- Random-Side Debate. Pair students up and assign each one a side at random. Each gets one minute to argue it, then they switch.
- Advisory Survey Project. Students survey other classes with one question and turn the results into percentages and a chart.
- Student Host Rotation. Each day, a different student picks the question and leads the short discussion.
Keep each routine under five minutes so it supports the lesson instead of replacing it. Let students suggest questions for a weekly student pick, and check them before you use them. Preview questions and skip any about money, appearance, or family situations. The free printable cards PDF on this page works well for early finishers and substitute plans.
Frequently asked questions
Are these would you rather questions appropriate for middle school?
Yes. Every question is clean and classroom-safe, with no dating, crushes, violence or mature topics. They focus on school life, friends, technology, sports, hobbies and future goals that 11 to 14 year olds actually care about.
How can teachers use would you rather questions in middle school?
Use them as morning meeting warm-ups, advisory discussion starters, two-minute brain breaks or exit tickets. They also work as persuasive writing prompts and quick debate topics where students must defend their choice with clear reasons.
Can parents use these questions at home?
Absolutely. They are great for dinner table talk, car rides and family game nights. Asking why your child picked an option is an easy way to learn about their friends, interests and hopes without it feeling like an interview.