About this episode
The internet's favorite silly question, in a friendly foam noodle version. One giant duck the size of a horse, or a hundred tiny horses the size of ducks. Nobody gets hurt, but somebody has to make a plan, and the plans people come up with are the best part.
Vote and see what everyone picked: https://wouldyourather.info/would-you-rather/one-horse-sized-duck-or-100-duck-sized-horses/
Play 3,000+ clean questions free: https://wouldyourather.info/
A new question every day: https://wouldyourather.info/question-of-the-day/
Read the full transcript
Auto-generated transcript; small mistakes are possible.
Welcome to today's deep dive So when you think about epic duels you usually picture, I don't know gleaming armor intense music high stakes, right? a very serious very tactical Situation exactly. Mm-hmm. But today well, we are trading the broad swords for foam pool noodles Oh nice. Yeah, we are looking at a duel where absolutely nobody gets hurt a totally kids safe friendly scenario We're tackling the ultimate internet dilemma, which is Would you rather fight one horse sized duck or 100 duck sized horses? It really is like the perfect strategic sandbox it is But I have to ask why do absurd hypotheticals like this?
Instantly capture our attention like you hear the question and suddenly your brain is just forced into full-on tactical planning mode Well, it's because these questions sort of trick our brains We end up applying real-world physics to you know, literal looney-tune scenarios. Oh, that makes sense Yeah, so take the giant duck for instance our sources point out some really distinct tactical advantages to choosing Just the single massive adversary like what just that there's only one of them mostly yeah, you aren't splitting your attention in a hundred different directions and Functionally your brain immediately starts calculating the biomechanics of an oversized bird, right?
And you quickly realize it would actually be incredibly slow on land Wait, really? I always pictured a giant duck being super fast and terrifying. Why would it be slow? It comes down to mass versus structure. So bird legs evolved to carry lightweight bodies, right with hollow bones Yeah, that's true So if you scale a duck to the volume of a horse the mass increases exponentially But the leg structure doesn't fundamentally change. Oh, I see so it can't support itself. Well, exactly It wouldn't just be clumsy. Its own weight would severely restrict its movement that gives you a massive mobility advantage So I should be picturing this like a classic video game boss fight Basically, that is a great way to look at it like it looks huge and takes up the whole screen But its center of gravity is a complete mess So I just wait for its predictable heavy attack sidestep and then you know, bop it with my foam noodle Plus if you win, I mean you had the absolute best story anyone has ever told That is the theory anyway But uh, if you miss time that sidestep, you still have a thousand pounds of feathers crashing down on you Oh, yeah, fair point that It actually sounds a bit too high stakes for a pool noodle fight I think I'd almost rather take my chances with the hundred tiny horses going for the swarm approach.
Yeah Because at least I have a distinct height advantage, right? Well, the swarm strategy holds up surprisingly Well, especially when you look at the physical limitations of those tiny horses because they're so small biologically speaking Yes, a hundred mini horses would have to take like 10 or 20 steps for every one of yours. Oh, wow I didn't think about the stride length Right. So their energy expenditure would just be off the charts meaning they would tire out Incredibly quickly and I guess if I get overwhelmed I literally just step over them and jog away precisely You have an escape route built directly into the physics of the encounter Honestly, this sounds less like a tactical retreat and more like being surrounded by a hundred to hyperactive puppies It really does paint a cute picture Yeah, I mean the real danger here might just be getting overwhelmed by cuteness the source is even note They're adorable and you know They might just want to cuddle instead of a duel which completely shifts the parameters of the scenario Honestly, and the source material actually reveals a surprising alternative strategy from the creators of the prompt themselves Wait, the original creators weighed in they did Bonus points actually go to anyone who suggests making friends with their opponents instead of fighting them Oh, I love that see that completely changes the game.
It really does We think we're debating physics and tactics, but we're actually just giving our brains a structured playground for the imagination The real joy of this question isn't the imaginary combat It's the wildly creative absurd plans people come up with to handle the whole situation It's applying serious logic to a ridiculous premise, you know, whether that is biomechanics or just pure diplomacy So I want to leave you with a new question to ponder kind of circling back to that intense gladiator arena. We started in okay Let's hear it. If you did choose the peaceful route and you made friends with your opponent Which logistical nightmare would be worse for your backyard?
Feeding one giant horse sized duck or housing 100 tiny hyperactive horses. Oh Man, that requires some serious long-term municipal planning right there. It really does, right? So we want you to finally pick a side Once you have your ultimate strategy in mind cast your vote and see what everyone else picked at would you rather dot info?
